Just like the members of Fleetwood Mac, or the Mamas & the Papas, or the Beatles, or Van Halen, the rock band on the heart of the Broadway play Stereophonic can’t appear to maintain its act collectively. The bassist stumbles drunk and late right into a recording session; the guitarist retains futzing with the tempo on a tune. The musicians are clearly shut with each other—plenty of inside jokes, plenty of informal touching—however that solely makes the bickering extra private.

David Adjmi’s play, which on Sunday evening gained 5 Tony awards together with Finest Play, follows the rising schisms amongst 5 members of an unnamed Seventies rock band as they file their sophomore album. Stereophonic attracts closely from the period’s rock-and-roll aesthetics: brown-toned, closely carpeted decor; vibrant, guitar-heavy songs written by the previous Arcade Hearth member Will Butler; copious quantities of booze, weed, and cocaine mendacity round. The present has drawn the strongest comparisons to Fleetwood Mac, particularly as a result of the band’s core couple appears to reflect the tumultuous relationship between the singer Stevie Nicks and the guitarist Lindsey Buckingham. This very actual human messiness is the draw—the sense of constructing it up as they go results in thrilling discoveries, nevertheless it additionally fosters nervousness and doubt. The tip end result could also be nice music, however Stereophonic leaves us questioning whether or not it was well worth the sacrifices required to get there.

Stereophonic takes place solely inside the locus of any band’s inventive life: the studio. As married couple Reg (Will Brill, who gained an appearing Tony on Sunday) and Holly (Juliana Canfield)—who’s planning on transferring out of the shared home the place everybody lives collectively—argue about their relationship, they achieve this in entrance of their bandmates, plus the sound engineers. In the meantime, the guitarist Peter (Tom Pecinka) needles his girlfriend, Diana (Sarah Pidgeon), a singer who will get so nervous about what to do together with her fingers onstage that she takes up the tambourine. Regardless of their idiosyncrasies, they’re united within the pursuit of rock stardom, a dream that turns into extra sensible as their first album begins to climb the charts. However by holding the motion remoted from the payoff of recognition, Adjmi is ready to maintain a spotlight as a substitute on how that success adjustments the group, then tears them aside.

Learn: Daisy Jones and the entice of the love triangle

Because the recording classes drag out, the tensions ratchet up; some scenes start after midnight. However it’s throughout a few of their worst private moments that a very powerful musical triumphs happen. In a single scene, Diana is having bother hitting the excessive word in a tune known as “East of Eden,” by which a narrator implores a lover to keep away from making a false alternative between two suitable life paths. Peter appears to be centered on the long run—perfecting the album, having a toddler with Diana. She is much less sure, and nonetheless processing the celebrity they’re experiencing now; she typically frets about not being sensible or proficient sufficient. She and Peter find yourself arguing offstage, with scorching mics that enable the engineers (and the viewers) to listen to every thing, and break up. Nonetheless, she returns to the microphone for one more take—and at last hits the word.

The second is greater than a satisfying triumph within the narrative; there’s a bittersweet but voyeuristic attract to watching knowledgeable excessive observe private struggling. One real-world analogue is Fleetwood Mac’s 1997 efficiency of “Silver Springs,” a recording of which periodically goes viral. On the time, 20 years had handed because the band launched its rollicking magnum opus, Rumours, and the traditional lineup—Nicks, Buckingham, Christine and John McVie, and Mick Fleetwood—hadn’t labored collectively full-time in a decade. As she sings, Nicks focuses her intense gaze on Buckingham, nearly like she’s attempting to curse him. They’d joined the band as a pair, musically and romantically, and broke up whereas Rumours was in manufacturing; the tune’s title refers to a Washington, D.C., suburb that got here to symbolize the life Nicks and Buckingham would by no means have collectively. We, because the viewers, get the fun of experiencing a fantastic efficiency and observing the tantalizing context, considerably masking the sharpness of the very actual strife that prompted it. The inverse is true for Diana: Her success can’t absolutely distract from the ache of understanding that her partnership with Peter is really over.

There’s an impulse to recast one’s struggles in a optimistic gentle when trying again: Every thing is value it as a result of it obtained me so far. Close to the tip of the present, Diana does this herself. After a sound engineer describes the recording course of as a “nightmare,” she rebuffs him, saying, “This was the perfect factor that ever occurred to me.” However the sentiment falls considerably flat after the viewers watches the band splinter over the course of three hours, for the sake of one thing we by no means see in its ultimate type (only some songs are carried out in full, although the present launched a full forged album). The notion of excellent coming from dangerous is a romantic one, however the actuality isn’t a zero-sum sport. No quantity of recognition will essentially fill the hole left by somebody you really liked; perfection doesn’t essentially negate the technique of attaining it.

And so the present’s actual heartbreak is watching the band’s shaggy enthusiasm get replaced with cool professionalism. There isn’t one big combat that breaks them aside. As an alternative, you watch every member’s dedication—to the music, to at least one one other—dwindle till getting all of them in the identical room on the similar time is tough. The loss isn’t simply the music, however the folks they was. At one level, Peter breaks down, tearfully pleading to Diana: “Say you’re my household.” Possibly they have been household as soon as, or one thing near it—however that was a special time, one immortalized in wax after which left behind.